15.
Christianity in Southwestern China: Mass Conversion among the Miao and Yi
Zeng Shicai
Thirty-four
ethnic minorities live in southwest China, and their populations number
34,000,000. These minorities still retain their own traditions in spite of
interaction and integration with the "great tradition" of the Han
Chinese. In the 19th century, after the Opium War (1839-42) and the Arrow
Affair (1856-60), many foreigners entered the hinterland. Contact with
missionaries exposed the minorities to Christianity and then another form of
acculturation began to take place.
Generally
speaking, Christianity has never gained an important place in Han Chinese
religious life (Fried, 1987), but
it did expand among some of the ethnic minorities on the border. Mass
conversion among the Miao and Yi peoples is a typical example. They live in the
Weining area in north west Guizhou and Zhaotong in north east Yunnan, both
remote areas of these provinces. The movement started from the 1900s and a
large number of them were converted to Christianity. This article aims to
analyse the history and the present state of Christianity in this area. It
seeks to examine the reasons why Christianity spread among the Yi and Miao, it
reviews the means by which Christianity diffused, and the process of
acculturation, and it comments on the syncretism of Christianity after
Liberation.[1]
Before Christianity
Climate and ethnicity
Yunnan and
Guizhou Provinces, located in southwestern China, lie on the Yungui heights. In
northeastern Yunnan and northwestern Guizhou, the elevation averages over 2,000
meters above sea level. The weather is cold and there is a rain deficiency. In
Weining, for example the average temperature is 10.6 degrees Centigrade and
they only have 971.4 mm of rain on average in a year. In addition there are so
many limestone
mountains, eroded over a long period, that it is very hard to engage in farming
rice. Mountain slopes are used for grazing cattle and goats, and agriculture is
conducted on the plains. The main crops are Irish potatoes, maize, buckwheat
and oats.
The reason
why the Chinese had not entered this area earlier was due to the harshness of
its natural environment. Chinese people called this land guifang or "demon's
region" and they regarded the non-Chinese inhabitants as barbarians. The
inhabitants were also called loushi gui or "mud snail demon",
which referred to the spiral form in which some of them did up their hair (Clarke, 1911: 5).
Some local
chiefs of the Yi remained independent in this area, until their suppression by
Wu Sangui in 1644. For example, the Lu clan were de facto rulers of Wumeng, the
centre of which was Zhaotong, and the An clan ruled Wusa, the centre of which
was Weining.
The Yi
people moved into northwestern Guizhou from eastern Yunnan in the Western Han
era, expelled the Gelao, the indigenous people, and established their own
regime. During the Yuan and the Ming, the central government appointed these
local chiefs as tusi, administrators of the natives, and ruled them indirectly.
Under this system the tusi could to a great extent remain autonomous. The Yi people
were divided into two classes, the Black Yi and the White Yi. The Black Yi, who
referred to themselves as No-su, "black men", were the patricians and
landowners while most of the White Yi were commoners.
The Yi were
not the original inhabitants of this region. According to No-su they came from
the north. Their origin appears in their story of the flood which reads as
follows (Kurihara, 1982). In the
age of Du-mu-e, the thirty-first descendant from the first ancestor, a flood
broke out as a punishment inflicted on mankind by the Heavenly King. The flood
killed all the people on the earth, but Lu alone survived because he followed
the advice of a hermit. After drifting for a long time, he arrived at Luo-yi
mountain where he started a new life. Later he married three celestial nymphs,
and had six children. These children were called "the six ancestors".
Ten generations later, the number of descendants of the six ancestors increased
and formed respectively six subgroups: Zha, Wu, Nuo, Heng, Bu and Mo.
In reality,
every tusi of the No-su during the Ming dynasty, in Yunnan, Guizhou, and Sichuan,
derived from the six ancestors. The Wu-meng clan were descendants of the Heng
group, for instance, and the Wu-sa were from the Bu group. Tusi constantly intermarried
for the sake of maintaining and forging alliances between groups. Their
positions and estates were succeeded to by their heirs, who were born from
legal wives. Furthermore they confirmed their sovereignty by appointing their
sons who were born from their concubines as tumu, "magistrate" (Kurihara, 1982).
Miao people
called themselves Hmong, but the Chinese dubbed them Huamiao,
"party-coloured Miao" after the women's embroidered costume. The Miao
population was greater than that of the Yi, but they were also not the original
inhabitants of this land. According to their story of ethnic migration, they
originally lived in the Yellow River valley. But they were defeated in battle
by the Han Chinese, and forced to move south to the mid-Yangzi river area.
Furthermore at the end of the Tang and the beginning of the Song dynasty, they
migrated further south into southwestern China.
In Guizhou,
they came under the control of the Yi tusi and tumu (Yang Hanxian, 1980). They became tenants or serfs like the
Gelao and the Bai. The following proverb described the position of the Miao
aptly: "there is no land for the Miao, there are no trees for crows to
perch on."
After Wu
Sangui suppressed the local chiefs of the Yi, a policy known as the gaitu
guiliu,
or the incorporation of aboriginal territories into the regular administrative
sphere, was introduced to abolish the tusi system. Nevertheless the tumu managed to maintain
their power and were appointed as assistants to officials. Besides the ground
rent, the Miao people owed the tumu many days' labour service during
the year. In reality, the tumu held practically the power of life and death over
his tenants. In addition, the political vacuum was not filled sufficiently
after the tusi system was abolished, so that quarrelling and fighting
about the division of land constantly occurred. Each time trouble arose among
the tumu, their Miao tenants were expected to serve as soldiers.
To sum up,
the ethnic relationships in this area after gaitu guiliu were between the tumu (the Black Yi),
commoners (the White Yi), and tenants (the Miao, the Gelao and the Bai).[2]
Meanwhile in the case of the Han Chinese they migrated into this land on a
large scale from the Ming era, and outnumbered the other ethnic groups. They
mainly lived in cities or surrounding areas. They despised the non-Han
inhabitants, but feared them at the same time. The Black Yi captured a
considerable number of Han Chinese and kept them as slaves.
Traditional spirits and magicians.
Clarke vividly describes the religious beliefs of the Miao and the Yi (1911:
60-88, 112-136). In Miao villages, the houses stood side by side. The Miao were
extremely united, and all affairs concerning the village administration were
decided fairly by the elders. On the other hand, in Yi society, differentiation
had progressed further. The Black Yi were divided into a few patricians and
many commoners. Even among the White Yi, there appeared tenants and serfs. In
regard to culture, the Yi were more assimilated with the Chinese than the Miao.
When the missionaries arrived, most of the Yi celebrated the Chinese New Year
festival, though some of them still observed New Year's Day on the first day of
the tenth month of the lunar calendar. They also worshipped Buddhist idols.
Even if
there were some differences in their assimilation into Chinese culture between
the Yi and Miao, they both believed in traditional spirits. For example typhoid
and malaria were rampant in the area, and the Yi and Miao attributed these
illnesses to evil spirits. In such cases, magicians and exorcists were summoned
and expected to cure patients with herbs, or to find the evil spirits which
caused the disease, and to exorcise them.
The Miao
called magicians ai-pi-san. If someone fell ill or had bad luck, this was
attributed to evil spirits, and magicians were summoned. If misfortune or
emergency befell a village, ai-pi-san would exorcise the evil spirits
from the village by killing a dog and hanging up a blood-stained wooden sword
with straw rope. At the same time, the Miao feared magicians because they had
the power to bewitch people by using gu or poison. In Miao society,
quarrels often occurred because of this, and in some cases the magicians were
expelled from their villages.
In the case
of the Yi, the si-ai served as both soothsayer and medical magician. There was a
more remarkable specialist called pu-mo. Yi society was patrilineal, and
each clan had its no-i which was equivalent to the Chinese family name. The pu-mo wrote the genealogy of
each clan in the old Yi script.
The diffusion and penetration of Christianity
Protestant missions and missionaries
According
to Latourette (1929), after the
Opium War (1839-42) and the Treaty of Nanjing (1842), not a few missionaries
came to China in order to start evangelising. To cope with the Arrow Affair
(1856-60), moreover, the Treaty of Tianjin (1858) and the Treaty of Beijing
(1860) were concluded between China and the Western powers. As a result, the
activities of the missionaries and the faith of the Chinese Christians received
protection under the treaties. Missionaries were even eager to go into the
border districts. In the Weining area, the United Methodist Mission, and the
China Inland Mission began propagating the gospel in earnest during the 1900s.
The United
Methodist Mission was established by the Wesley brothers in the 18th century.
The members of this society emphasised evangelism and social welfare, and
condemned drinking and immorality. The mission entered China in 1851.
The China
Inland Mission was founded by Hudson Taylor in 1865. Its headquarters were in
London, and there were branches in the United States and Australia. This
mission was organised for the purpose of evangelisation in China, and was
associated with several societies with similar objectives. The founder, Hudson
Taylor, after his arrival in China in 1854, spent his whole life there, except
for a two-year sojourn in England, and died in Changsha in 1905.
As for the
diffusion of Christianity on the Yungui plateau, we can refer to several
sources such as Clarke (1911), Yang Hanxian (1981), Wang and Li
(1986) and Zhang (1988).
According to these there were two missionaries who played important roles in
the expansion of Christianity in this area. One was Samuel Pollard, who first
opened the Zhaotong Mission House of the United Methodist Mission in Yunnan,
and later shifted the headquarters to Shimenkan ("Stone Gateway").
The other was J.R. Adam who worked in the Anshun station of the China Inland
Mission and frequently visited villages around Gebu. Their activities aroused
the suspicion and opposition of the ruling class. Not only the non-Chinese
Christians, but also the missionaries, suffered interference and persecutions
from the tumu. The missionaries tried to protect the converts at the risk of their
own lives.
Pollard,
Adam and their successors built many chapels, and also made efforts to
construct public facilities, such as schools, orphanages, leprosy hospitals,
and private post offices. In addition they tried to create scripts for writing
the Miao and Yi languages in order to allow these peoples to print their own
bibles. The non-Chinese peoples were extremely glad to be able to write down
their own languages in their own scripts (Tan,
1983; Yang Zongxin, 1984; Wei, 1985; Wang and Li,
1986).
In most
instance, the two Christian missions maintained cooperative relationships with
each other. As the number of non-Chinese Christians swelled, the missions had
to increase their activities. In a sense, both missions were competing with
each other for converts. To mark out spheres of influence, Pollard, Adam and
other missionaries held a conference in the Dasongshu Church of Fadi. At this
conference, they decided on the the crest of the Shaopu Mountains as the
boundary, and agreed that the China Inland Mission would work in the area to
the southeast of the line, and that the United Methodist Mission would work to
the northwest.
In 1915
Adam was killed by lightning at night. In the same year, typhoid raged in
Shimenkan, and many of the pupils of the mission school were stricken. Pollard
had a hard time nursing them. He also contracted the disease and died. In spite
of this the two missions continued their work until all foreign missions left
the area in 1949.
The wild boar incident and the Duanwu festival
Anshun
Mission Station was opened in 1888 by Adam. While working and preaching among
the Chinese, he was frequently in contact with the Miao around Anshun. By
giving them quinine and other remedies for malaria, he gained their confidence.
Later he began to visit their villages and learned their language. However, at
that period the Miao were afraid of what the Chinese might say if they showed
friendship to a missionary or received him in their houses. So the number of
converts did not greatly increase. In 1900, the year of the Boxer Rebellion,
the Dowager Empress issued an edict ordering all foreigners in the provinces to
be put to death. Foreign missionaries took refuge in Shanghai. The Acting
Governor hesitated and did not obey the order, for fear that the western powers
would take revenge. A rumour passed around Anshun that all Christians would be
killed. It is not hard to imagine that the converts were terrified during the
absence of the missionaries. In fact, thirty Miao in Guizhou were put to death
that year, on the grounds that they were Christians.
When Adam
returned to Anshun in 1901, he began to preach in earnest among the Miao. In
1902 he visited the north side of the Sancha River, an area which no foreigners
had previously visited. The north side was originally the estates of the Shuixi
An clan (descendants of Mo, according to the "six ancestors" legend)
where the Yi tumu landowners ruled even after the tusi were abolished.
Adam
visited a village called Dengdui during his first journey to the north side
where he prayed for a dead person and evangelised among the villagers. The
local people were much impressed, and interest rapidly spread from village to
village, and in a short time people from many villages attended the services at
Anshun. In 1905, a chapel was built in Dengdui and one hundred Miao Christians
and two hundred others attended the services. He was given an enthusiastic
welcome wherever he went.
One day in
1903 four Miao hunters, including Li Matai, met Adam on their way back from
chasing a wild boar. Adam gave them a warm reception, serving them with coffee
and milk. He persuaded them that they would not be insulted if they became
Christians. He invited them to consult with him when they had any trouble. They
lived in Lanlongqiao (about two days from Anshun) in that time, but they
formerly lived in Xinlongchang of Gebu (now called Xinglongchang, nine days
from Anshun), and migrated to Lanlongqiao because of population increase.
Later on an
incident occurred in which a landowner robbed Li Matai's group taking their
wild boar. Li and other members came to Anshun and resorted to Adam. Adam
lodged a strong protest to Anshunfu (the district office). The office ordered
the landowner to give compensation for the loss, because the Chinese government
had agreed not to persecute its Christian subjects in the treaties of Tianjin
and Beijing. The Miao believed that Jesus was Klang Meng, the "Miao
king". In the winter of the same year, a memorial festival for the
ancestor was held in Xinlongchang. This ceremony was conducted on a large scale
every twelve years. Li Matai attended the festival and told the villagers of
his old home that the Miao King had appeared in Anshun. He advised them to
attend the service. Luo Yabo, the leader of this festival, showed a keen
interest in it, and went to meet Adam with his brother-in-law, and Li Matai.
They returned and gave an account of all they had seen and heard. The people in
their village however, were not satisfied, and sent a second deputation the
next year, this time composed of seven men, including Luo Yabo, Luo Danyili,
and Zhang Baoluo. From that time on they visited Anshun in groups of twenty,
forty, fifty or more. In some years the number exceeded a hundred.
It took ten
days to reach Anshun, an arduous trek over mountains. Besides the Chinese
despised them, and on the way they could not stay at Chinese inns. One man
contracted smallpox on the way and died in the mission compound. Adam decided
to build a chapel in Gebu and so asked Pollard to preach to the people living
in outlying areas, for it was only two or three days distance from Zhaotong to
the northwest edge of Guizhou Province. They did not know Pollard and hesitated
to go to meet him at first. Pollard was given an open-hearted welcome by the
people living on the northwest edge of Guizhou. Soon after this he went to
Weining District with Luo Danyili and his wife, who were Miao Christians whom
Pollard had baptised. Pollard built a chapel in Shimenkan the next year, 1904.
That year was the year of the Dragon, and the Miao people worshipped the dragon
as sacred. They were very glad to know Pollard and said that they were awakened
spiritually in the year of the dragon. On the other hand, Zhang Baoluo who was
baptised in Anshun went back to his home town of Gebu, and propagated the
faith. A thousand-seat chapel was built in 1906 with Adam's help.
An English
missionary who succeeded Adam, called in Chinese Pei Zongqian (his English name
is not known), moved to Gebu in 1917 in order to learn more about the Miao
language and customs. After this, several foreign missionaries took turns
living there. In 1918 the crops failed in the Weining and Hezhang areas. In the
winter of that year, Pei with twenty-four preachers visited Yi villages around
Magu and Bandi and gave them provisions and cash. At that time a feud was
brewing between Duo'e Tumu and Huomo Tumu over the question of a successor to
the Zumu Tumu who ruled Ertang. Large numbers of young men were killed in
skirmishes. The Yi appealed to Pei to convert them to Christianity. It seemed,
on the other hand, that Pei and his followers took advantage of Yi practices in
order to increase the number of converts among the Yi. The next spring a famine
occurred again, and many people starved to death. Pei made it known that he
would sacrifice five oxen in the Duanwu Festival, held on the fifth day of the
fifth lunar month, and that they would be welcome to take part in the feast, so
as to obtain food and other commodities. Thus the missionaries obtained
influence among the Yi around Hezhang, Weining and Shuicheng by distributing
food and other goods.
Mass conversion and social disturbances
The work of
the two missions was concentrated in different areas. The United Methodist
Mission established the Shimenkan Church as its central headquarters, and
mainly worked in the northwest of Guizhou, the east of Yunnan and the south of
Sichuan. They reputedly built fifty chapels and converted 60,000 non-Chinese
Christians between 1905 and 1920. On the other hand, the China Inland Mission
divided the Weining parish into the Miao area and the Yi area in 1920. The Gebu
church and the Jiegou church respectively became their central churches. In the
Miao area, twenty-one chapels were reported by 1937 and 7,000 Christians by
1938. In the Yi area they built thirty five chapels by 1934, though the number
of converts was unclear. Conversions were made not so much in consequence of
the travelling and preaching of the missionaries, as by the zeal and persistent
testimony of the believers.
Judging
from the wild boar incident which led the Miao to convert en masse, they were warmly
treated as equals, and what they had to say was listened to for the first time
in their lives. Troubles over marriage or land often occurred among the Miao.
They solved problems related to marriage themselves, but the Yi landowners had
the power to judge cases related to land issues. The Miao were often treated
unjustly by these landowners. Appeals to Chinese officials rarely yielded
satisfactory results as these officials were bribed by the landowners.
With a
history of oppression, the Miao regarded Jesus Christ as a saviour king endowed
with magical power. Many of the leaders in Miao revolts claimed to be Miao
kings. It was for this reason that the Miao people first resorted to the church
and converted to Christianity. Mass conversion among the Yi began fourteen
years after that of the Miao. It was quarrels among the tumu and crop failures that
drove the White Yi into the Christian fold.
We can
discern differences in the reaction to Christianity among the Han Chinese, the
Miao and the Yi. In the case of the Han Chinese they were more keen on
obtaining knowledge about science than about Jesus. Confucianism seems to be
inconsistent with Christianity, because the former is based on Han Chinese
ancestor worship, while the latter demands absolute obedience to God from
believers. The number of Christians did not increase at that time. The Miao,
who were desperately poor, were especially keen to take on Christianity. What
they tried to clarify first of all was whether Jesus was their true saviour or
not.
After
seventeen years' stay in Zhaotong, Pollard had made many Chinese friends, but
few converts. His friends often asked him silly questions, though he longed for
a heart-to-heart talk about the things which really mattered. For example,
"Have you a moon in your country?", "Do women rule in your
country?" Still more stupid was "Have your people a hole right
through the chest through which a pole is put when they are carried out?"
(Pollard, 1919: 38). Apparently
his friends imagined western countries to be like Guanxiongguo in the ancient
geography book Shanhaijing, where strange people lived with poles through their
chests. Miao who wanted information asked none of these silly questions. Their
one request was "Give us books and teach us about Jesus" (Pollard, 1919: 38).
When Miao
converted to Christianity, they broke with convention. They made a bonfire, and
then burnt the drums used in offerings to traditional spirits, magicians'
wands, with other instruments and charms. Furthermore, some women threw their
necklets into the fire. These necklets were charms for protection, which the
magician had told them to wear. Women also burnt their "spirit
packets" in their homes. These "spirit" packets were made up by
the magician or exorcists, and kept as charms to ward off evil spirits which
might attack children.
Towards the
end of 1904, the movement had influenced the whole region from Gebu to
Zhaotong. In the evening service, Miao people listened silently to the sermons.
There were plenty of songs and many short prayers. They especially liked
singing the hymns. Before chapels were built in each area hundreds, or
sometimes thousands, of people often gathered on hillsides to sing until
midnight, and sometimes till dawn. In extreme cases, the rumour went round that
Jesus was coming very soon. One group moved to the mission house and prayed for
the millennium. Interestingly enough, some of the magicians tried to play the
role of prophet.
The mass
conversion caused social malaise with regard to traditional order. Magicians
reacted directly against it. For instance, one magician imitated the rites of
Christian worship and deceived villagers. He led them to a pond and bathed them
there, collecting a substantial fee from each person for administering the
rite. Another woman called herself "Jesus's sister". In the former
case, the magician was out to make money. In the latter case the woman was a
wife of a magician, and while most of the villagers attended the church services,
the magician and his wife were left alone. The more the villagers became
interested in Christianity, the more quirky his wife became. What is
interesting is that this magician was the first man to become a believer in
"Jesus's sister". We can see a magician who was upset and impatient
in the midst of rapid change of values among the villagers.
Unrest
prevailed among the tumu and landowners too. They tried to turn villagers away from
Christianity by torturing them, confiscating their estates and setting fire to
their villages. The Chinese also had their doubts about the conversion of the
Miao. Rumours spread that the Miao would rise in revolt and that the Miao had
poisoned wells with poison which they had got from foreigners. Some Miao people
were beaten and robbed, while others were driven away from the markets.
Conflict and the revival movement
The
expansion of Christianity owed much to the devotion of missionaries. Mission
headquarters at first gave little financial support. In 1923, the China Inland
Mission put into effect the "three self" principles, namely
self-government, self-propagation, and self-support. They gradually cut back
financial support for each mission station, and in 1928 ended all assistance.
Some of the chapels collected money from the converts and became involved in
money-lending. As a result, the good relations between the missionaries and
believers were broken. What is worse, missionaries forged friendships with the tumu and landowners, even
though at first they had protected the believers from these groups.
The tumu and landowners had been
afraid that if the Miao people became Christians, they would lose all their
authority over their tenants who would refuse to pay rent. They persecuted
those tenants who converted. Missionaries, on the one hand, protected their
believers, and on the other hand assured the landowners that their tenants
would pay their rents and that they would not ask believers to work on Sundays
for the Church. Most of them readily gave their consent, and were pleased that
the missionaries should make better men and women of their tenants. Some of the
landowners attended the service and taught their tenants some sections of the
Gospel. Missionaries gradually noticed that their task was facilitated by the
conversion of peoples of the upper classes, and so this changed their attitudes
towards them from confrontation to cooperation. All of the pupils at the
mission school were poor Miao children at first, but Yi pupils from the upper
classes gradually increased. Some traders made use of the postal money order
system set up by the mission, and had close relations with them.
Old slogans
such as that, if people became Christians they would not have do do military
service, provide so many days' labour, or pay rent, no longer worked. Mission
activities declined in the mid 1920s, and the number of church members
decreased. For example, the membership of the United Methodist Mission fell by
46,000 between 1925 and 1931.
In 1932
some people from Anshun argued for the necessity of a revival. Their point was
that only the faith in God could cause people to be inspired by the Holy
Spirit. They demanded that believers thoroughly confess their sins. People
became excited, and as the revival movement was successful the number of church
members increased again.
The Gebu
church unified the Miao and Yi areas in 1940, while the revival movement was
expanding. When Japan was defeated in 1945, the revival movement reached a
peak. A Chinese preacher, Li Ji'an, visited Gebu and read aloud a newspaper
account of the victory. He preached to audiences of five or six hundred for
three days. He persuaded them to strive for the advancement of the church. He
sang and prayed continually, and became so excited that he could not stop
himself trembling.
The members
of the revival criticised the fact that the China Inland Mission was
conservative. They advocated that they should sing a "soul song" and
perform a "soul dance" in order to try their souls. They even
advocated that men and women should embrace and sleep together. They also often
gathered together on hills to eat beef. It is easy to imagine that a mass
spiritual uplift had been created and that the people participating were in a
state of mass hysteria. They probably indulged themselves in a physiological
catharsis. Interestingly enough, the "soul song", "soul
dance" and hill climbing are all associated with traditional Miao and Yi
practices.
One of the
reasons why mission activities slackened in the mid 1920s was because the
missionaries could not rectify social inequality or at least try to change it,
but we should take into account another reason which belongs to the cultural
sphere. Frictions often developed between Christian commandments and believers
due to the difference in cultural backgrounds. In the case of the United
Methodist Mission which aimed at teetotalism, the church was particularly
strict in regard to drinking and sexual immorality. Miao households made
alcoholic beverages and drank on both happy and mournful occasions. Prohibition
of this caused many believers to leave the church.
There was
also a clubhouse called huafang by the
Han Chinese in the Miao village where boys and girls met and could sleep. They
sang all night through and courted. One of the first things Pollard and his
associates did when they visited villages was to tear down these
"immoral" and "cursed" club houses (Pollard, 1919: 46, 135). The Miao had practised monogamy but
they still courted quite openly before marriage, and their courting practices
were not regarded as moral by the missionaries. On the fifth day of the fifth
lunar month every year, the Yi and the Miao climbed mountains where they held a
musical festival. Boys and girls paired off to sing love songs to each other,
and the girls danced to bamboo pipe music played by the boys. This was a great
occasion for courting, but the church forbade these traditional songs and
dances.
The Miao
looked up the Jesus and the missionaries as the Messiah, and broke with the
past without hesitation. Afterwards, when they noticed that Jesus and the
missionaries were not the true Messiahs as far as they were concerned,
complaints about strict rules erupted. Many believers left the church. It may
be said that this "revival" was just a revival of their traditions.
Christianity in the new China
The present situation of Christianity
The
religious policy of the PRC is clearly set out in the constitution:
"Citizens of the People's Republic of China enjoy freedom of religious
belief", but "no one may use religion to conduct
counter-revolutionary activities". Furthermore, "no religious affairs
may be dominated by a foreign country" (Article 35 of the Revised
Constitution of the PRC). Chinese Christian leaders issued the "three
self" manifesto in 1950 (originally implemented in the 1920s) and later
Chinese churches broke of their relationships with foreign countries (i.e. the
Vatican for Catholics, and Great Britain and the United States for Protestants).
After 1957, the "radical leftists" closed down all the churches, and
many church members were persecuted. In 1979, three years after the fall of the
"Gang of Four" the church activities recommenced (Jiang, 1983; Wang and Ji,
1990).
After the
policy of religious toleration was publicly reinstated in 1979, the number of
Christian believers increased, and several million copies of the Bible have
been published to date. According to the UBS World Report (United Bible
Societies, 1989), this includes versions in some minority languages, such as
Miao, Yi, Lisu, Korean, and Jingpo. As for Christianity among the Miao and Yi,
detailed information has not been released, but Wang
Tingsheng and Wang Guolin (1990)
have reported that there were 35,000 believers in Guizhou Province just after
Liberation, of which Miao and Yi accounted for 70%. They also reported that now
the Christian population in the northwest of Guizhou numbered 70,000. Most of
them are probably Miao and Yi. It may safely be said that Christianity has
taken root in their corner of China. Witness the following case of a Yi village
called Bandi which I visited in 1986.
It is
located in Yancang District, Weining County, and consists of four hamlets.
According to Li, it has a
population of 1,174, of which 1,103 are Christian, that is 94% (Li, 1985). Christianity was introduced
into this village in 1917, and a church was built two years later. The number
of believers was 500 in 1925, and 800 in 1942. After all it turned out that the
strict rules were inconsistent with the Yi's traditional ways of drinking and
courting. Many people left the church, but membership doubled once the revival
movement began. Under the influence of the revival movement, new believers were
not baptised and did not obey the precepts of Christianity. The only thing they
did do was dance. Dancing was, in a way, their way of praying. Some attended
meetings for courtship. Some attended them only to enjoy the festive mood. Some
became believers lest they should be isolated from the other villagers.
In 1958 a
people's commune was set up in the village and the church was destroyed by the
"radical leftists". The authorities concerned regarded the church
members as "counter-revolutionary", and
"anti-establishment". Believers were often forced to go underground
and they often held meetings
outdoors in secret at night. Believers still accounted for 85% of all villagers
during the Cultural Revolution. After the "Gang of Four" fell from
power in 1977, society returned to normal, and the believers gradually came out
into the open, rebuilding their church in 1983. Though there was no official
pastor in the village in 1986, the senior members acted as substitutes. Every Sunday many believers from
adjoining districts and counties attended the church services. Ordinary
activities include village-level meetings every Wednesday and every Friday. In
addition, several churches joined together and held a mass-meeting every month
or every other month.
Syncretism and the future of Christianity
Church
activities have changed the way of life of the Yi and Miao. For example, a Yi
bride used to abstain from food before marriage in the old days. On the day of
the wedding her brother would carry her to the door without letting her touch
the earth, and put her on a horse. But today, to the singing of Christian
hymns, she is received by the groom's side at the door. There is no fasting and
riding now. Courtship singing, swing festivals and wrestling tournaments as
agricultural rites have been abolished (Li,
1985: 351).
As regards
religious beliefs, they still worship the ancestors at their New Year (on the
first day of the tenth lunar month in the Chinese calendar) at their homes,
though all the ancestral halls have disappeared. it seems that the ancestors
coexist with Protestant belief. Li
points out that they pay great attention to fengshui geomancy. When they
build a house, they often look for longmai or "dragon's veins". If a
disaster happens in a family, they often move the family tomb. Li also points out that a new type of
magician has come into being. When someone is ill, several Christian believers
come to read a few sections of the Bible and to dance beside the patient. These
believers claimed that this endows them with inspiration (Li, 1985: 350-51).
The Miao
and Yi did not completely abandon their traditions when they converted. They
sang hymns to their own melodies, and accepted Jesus as an ethnic hero in the
case of the Miao. This indicates that their conversion to Christianity was
achieved within the framework of their own traditions, and this is precisely
the reason why they did not lose their own ethnic identity with conversion.
Li
also refers to an educational problem. At the five-year elementary school in
Bandi, the percentage of school attendance was 95% during the Cultural
Revolution, but it dropped to 30% in 1978, and has levelled off, though the
political situation remains stable. The branch secretary of the Communist Party
attributes this fall to the current emphasis on making money as well as on
church activities, but he thinks that the church is mainly to blame. The
secretary points out that the percentage of school dropouts is very high and
that a large number of pupils attend the church activities after giving up
school. As regards money making, it has become a nation-wide tendency after the
implementation of the responsibility system for production. Farmers' households
did not let their children attend school because they need their labour. As for
church activities, I have one point to add. As a rule, all classes are held in
the Chinese language at Bandi elementary school. Though third and fourth grade
pupils can learn the new Yi script, created by the PRC and based on the old Yi
script, at school, this is a part of the new curriculum that started not long
before I visited the village. On the other hand pupils can read the bible
written in the Yi script created by Pollard and sing hymns in the Yi language
in church, so they seem to find church activities more appealing than
elementary school. The church, so to speak, is a cultural centre for
maintaining and strengthening their ethnic identity. The problem which the
branch secretary pointed to is due to the nature of the educational system
rather than to church activities per se.
In recent
years, Christianity has been growing and spreading among the Han Chinese,
especially in the rural districts, but general whole families and villages have
not converted. For example, in a certain county of Anhui Province, 73.8% of
Christians in a meeting place are women. As for the age range of Christians,
women over 50 constitute 53% in this instance (Luo,
1991: 233-234). Han Min, who
carried out research in Su County and Xiao County of Suxian Prefecture in
Anhui, also refers to a boom in Christianity (Han,
1993: 285-307). According to her report, after the adoption of the household
production system, those who have access to sufficient labour, technology and
cash become rich, while those who have insufficient labour, or who have to look
after the sick at home, live in poverty. In addition, the breakup of the
communes has affected the welfare system in the rural areas. Medical payments
have increased so that many old poor people cannot afford them. It is against
this background that Christianity appears to attract people by helping them
solve their problems.
According
to Han's report, there are three
main reasons why Christianity is growing rapidly. First of all, many recent
converts came to believe in the religion because they themselves or members of
their families had fallen ill and failed to recover. The medical services
provided by the churches are a means of attracting poor people with health
problems. Secondly many people converted to Christianity because of family
problems such as ill-treatment of parents or bad relationships between mothers
and daughters-in-law. They became cheerful and patient after their conversion.
Third, some people converted because of loneliness. In the case of widows or
those who lived alone, they felt lonely till conversion. Christianity not only
gives them encouragement to overcome this loneliness, but also fills a
spiritual vacuum (Han, 1993:
298-300).
Han also points out that Christianity in China stresses ethical relations
in this world in order to adapt to China's situation, because Confucian
ideology with its emphasis on ethics has long been dominant. Therefore local
officials generally do not interfere with Christian services. They even hope
that Christianity will play a more important role in the creation of a
socialist spiritual civilisation (Han,
1993: 304). She also told me that generally within a single family, if some
members convert to Christianity others do not, because no one would be able to
offer incense to the ancestors if all the members converted.
On the
other hand, in the case of the Miao and Yi, Christianity is treated with
indifference by local officials. As for the scale of conversion, whole families
and villages have converted. I discovered one interesting fact during my
research in a Yi village. The village is located in Zhongshan District, Weining
County. It has a population of ninety, and the total number of houses is
eighteen. This village consists of four clans. The Zhao clan is the dominant
clan, and it has eleven households. The whole village converted except for four
households. All four are members of the Zhao clan. In addition, they include
two local cadres. It is very interesting that these four households worship
their ancestors eagerly, while others are cool towards ancestor worship. The
ancestral hall of the Zhao clan was rebuilt after the fall of the "Gang of
Four" and the memorial tablet written in the old Yi script was installed
there, but only these four households go to offer incense to the tablet every
year. If those who worship their ancestors can be said to stand for the
indigenous cultures based on family ties, the church is a symbol of Yi unity
above the level of consanguineous relations. The reason why the local cadres
take sides with the former may be that the former is much safer to the
establishment than the latter.
When we
review the process by which Christianity diffused and the pattern of
acculturation, it is evident that it did not replace the indigenous religion,
but absorbed elements of it. In the revival which aimed at returning to the
indigenous tradition, they rectified
distortions brought about by the excessive denial of this tradition, and
attempted to restore social stability as well as to revitalise their ethnic
culture. Will they continue to revitalise their own tradition in future? Will
this Christian power lead to a national independence movement as Buddhism has
done in Tibet? It all depends upon how the present regime deals with them.
Notes
1. Twelve research trips
were made to study the traditional cultures of ethnic minorities in south China
between 1982 and 1991. As for the Miao and Yi in this area, Torii Ryuzo, who was the first
ethnologist in Japan to study them, pointed out the similarities between their
folk cultures and those of Japan. As far as Weining is concerned, Torii did not go there. As a member of a
study group which aims to collect first hand materials about folk customs based
on agriculture, I travelled in the Weining area in 1986. I stayed there for
only ten days but many materials were available. A book named Society and
Culture of a Mountain Village in South China: A Visit to Ethnic Minorities of
Northwestern Guizhou, edited by Tsuboi
Yobun, was published by the National Museum of Japanese History in 1989. I
found a large number of Christians in villages during my stay. This is the
first time I have studied Christianity in southwestern China.
2. Apart from the ethnic
groups mentioned in this article, a considerable number of Hui people live in
this area. They are descendants of soldiers dispatched there in the Yuan and
Ming dynasties. Many Hui people disguised themselves as Han Chinese after the
uprising of Du Wenxiu was crushed by the Qing dynasty in 1877. The Hui are
Muslim and have nothing to do with the issue of conversion to Christianity, so
they are not dealt with in this article. As for the Bai, they are descendants
of officials of the Nanzhao Kingdom when it ruled this area during the Tang
dynasty. After the kingdom fell in 901, they were gradually reduced to poverty.
Some of them disguised themselves as Han Chinese or Yi.
Return to Contents page